LACP vs PAGP: What’s the Difference?
LACP and PAGP are two negotiation protocols commonly used in configuring Etherchannel for link redundancy in network devices. This post will compare Link Aggregation Control Protocol and Port Aggregation Protocol, specifically in terms of how they differ when aggregating links and redistributing the load in case of link failure. After reading this article, network administrators should have a clearer understanding of the differences between LACP and PAGP, helping them determine which protocol better suits their specific network environment.
What is LACP ？
LACP（Link Aggregation Control Protocol) is a protocol used to bundle multiple physical links into a logical link to increase bandwidth and provide redundancy in network connections. LACP is also known as 802.3ad, which is the IEEE standard that defines the protocol. Link Aggregation Control Protocol is commonly used in enterprise networks and is supported by many vendors, including Cisco. LACP allows multiple physical links between switches or between a switch and a server to be aggregated into a single logical link, which provides higher bandwidth and redundancy. This is achieved by distributing traffic evenly across the physical links, allowing for optimal use of network resources.
Advantages of LACP
Some of the benefits of LACP include:
1. Increased bandwidth
By bundling multiple physical links together, LACP allows for increased bandwidth between network devices. This can be particularly useful in situations where large amounts of data need to be transferred quickly, such as in data centers or for video streaming.
2. Improve Redundancy
LACP provides redundancy by ensuring that if one or more links in the aggregation fail, the remaining links can continue to carry the traffic with minimal disruption.
3. Load balancing
LACP distributes traffic across all available links, helping to balance the load and prevent any one link from becoming overloaded. This can help to improve overall network performance and reduce the risk of congestion.
4. Improved failover capabilities
If one of the links in an LACP bundle fails, traffic can automatically be rerouted to the remaining links in the bundle, helping to ensure that network connectivity remains available. This is crucial in mission-critical environments where high availability is required.
How Does LACP Work?
LACP works by establishing a link aggregation group (LAG) between two network devices, such as switches or routers, and negotiating the terms of the LAG. During the negotiation process, each device sends LACP packets to exchange information about its capabilities and preferences for the LAG. If the devices agree on the terms, they form a LAG and begin to exchange traffic over the aggregated links.
Once the LAG is established, LACP continues to monitor the status of the individual links in the group. If a link fails or becomes congested, LACP can automatically redistribute the traffic over the remaining links in the LAG, providing seamless failover and improved network performance.
LACP is a simple and efficient way to increase bandwidth and reduce downtime without requiring complex configuration or manual intervention.
How to Configure LACP on a Switch？
Configuring LACP (Link Aggregation Control Protocol) for a switch involves several steps.
1. Ensure that the switch supports LACP and that the connected devices are also capable of LACP.
2. Create a LAG (Link Aggregation Group) on the switch and assign the member ports to the LAG.
3. Configure the LACP mode for the LAG, which can be either Active or Passive mode. Active mode means that the switch will actively try to form a LAG with the connected devices, while Passive mode means that it will only respond to LACP requests from other devices.
4. Set the LACP timeout value, which determines how often LACP packets are sent between devices to maintain the LAG. Once these steps are completed, the LAG should be up and running, providing increased bandwidth and redundancy for the connected devices.
QSFPTEK offers a wide range of LACP-enabled switches, such as the 5300 Series, 5600 Series,7300 Series, 7600 Series
What is PAGP?
PAGP, short for Port Aggregation Protocol, is a technology used for EtherChannel that is exclusive to Cisco. Its main function is to automate the creation of EthernetChannels by facilitating the exchange of PAGP packets between ports. Through PAGP, switches can identify which of their counterparts support the protocol, allowing them to dynamically group similarly-configured ports into a single logical channel or aggregate port.It facilitates logical aggregation of Ethernet switch ports, allowing for data/traffic load balancing. With PAGP EtherChannel, up to 8 physical links can be combined into a single virtual link. Additionally, PAGP is an integral component of Cisco VSS (Cisco Virtual Switching System).
Advantages of PAGP
The advantages of PAGP are mainly the following three points：
1. Dynamic Negotiation:
PAGP provides dynamic negotiation of link aggregation between switches, which allows for optimal bandwidth utilization and link redundancy. This is achieved by dynamically adding or removing links from the LAG group based on the state of the links.
2. Hot Standby Links:
PAGP supports hot standby links, which allows for failover to a backup link in the event of a link failure. This provides additional redundancy and helps to ensure high availability of the network.
3. Loop Prevention:
PAGP provides a way to detect and prevent loops in the network. By using PAGP, the switches can detect when a loop has been created and take steps to prevent it from affecting the network.
How Does PAGP Work?
PAGP works by exchanging messages between switches to negotiate the formation of an EtherChannel, a LAG implemented in hardware. The messages include information such as the desired number of links in the bundle and the type of load balancing to be used. Once the negotiation is complete, the links are aggregated and treated as a single entity by the switches.
PAGP also supports hot-swapping of links, so if a link fails or is disconnected, the remaining links in the bundle continue to provide connectivity.
How to Configure PAGP on a Switch？
To configure PAGP on a switch, follow these steps:
1. Enable it globally using the "spanning-tree etherchannel" command.
2. Configure each physical port with the "channel-group" command, specifying the desired group number and mode (either "auto" or "desirable"). Auto mode means the port will only form an EtherChannel if the remote end is set to desirable or auto, while desirable mode means the port will always try to form an EtherChannel with the remote end.
3. Verify your configuration using the "show etherchannel summary" command to ensure that all ports have been correctly aggregated.
LACP vs PAGP: What's the Difference?
A detailed comparison between both LACP vs PAGP is enlisted in the below table
Conclusion
While LACP and PAGP share similarities, they vary in their configuration modes and mechanisms for aggregation. Choosing between the two depends on identifying the protocol (PAGP or LACP) supported by your device interface, and configuring whether negotiation should occur. Link Aggregation Control Protocol, being an IEEE-based protocol, is commonly used to bundle links and achieve maximum throughput between wiring closets and data centers. while Cisco's Port Aggregation Protocol is in demand in networks with Cisco equipment and PAGP negotiation support. To ensure proper protocol identification and configuration, each network device interface should be configured accordingly.
share
